UPDATE (see below)On the night of the first GOP debate, NBC political director Chuck Todd posted a note to MSNBC debate website claiming that Governor Huckabee had been "Caught in a Lie" when he claimed he had not attacked Romney's faith in a prior television appearance.
Overwhelmingly the transcript of the prior interview, public opinion,
and Romney supporters themselves ALL say Todd was wrong -- Huckabee did not lie.
Since the night of the debate we have been pursuing Chuck Todd in an effort to get him to correct his slanderous accusation.
To his credit, today we heard from him. Here's his email.
Subject: FW: 16 Hours Since Chuck Todd Slandered Mike Huckabee: Where's Chuck?
Date: Mon, 7 May 2007 09:44:29 -0400
From: "Todd, Chuck D (NBC Universal)"
To: bluestaterepublican@yahoo.com
i was referring to a question Huckabee was directly asked about Romney's religious faith in a previous interview... I read Huckabee's response at the time as a shot at RomneyLets analyze this for a moment. Todd says "I read Huckabee's response
at the time as a shot at Romney" is not quite a correction or an apology, but it certainly seems to be a bit of a retreat from "HUCKABEE CAUGHT IN A LIE." We've emailed Mr. Todd to confirm whether he still thinks Huckabee lied. We assume he doesn't, in which case we are going to want to know if Mr. Todd plans to publicly correct his statement, which was seen by thousands of visitors to the MSNBC blog, or whether he thinks his little ol' email to little ol' us is enough.
We'll keep you posted.
UPDATE: No further comment yet from Mr. Todd in reference to our email looking for clarification, but we notice something interesting. He emailed us at 9:44 AM this morning and said "I read Huckabee's response
at the time as a shot at Romney."
Then, just 5 minutes later, at 9:49 AM, he posted
this comment on the original "Huckabee Lied" story on the MSNBC blog:
"Lie" was strong... I'll admit that... but he did mislead viewers. He absolutely was being critical of Romney at the time.
(Sent Monday, May 07, 2007 9:49 AM)Hmmm. Hold on a second.
9:44 AM to BSR: "I read Huckabee's response
at the time as a shot at Romney."
9:49 AM to the MSNBC blog: "He absolutely was being critical of Romney at the time."
Do these statements, coming only 5 minutes apart, seem inconsistent to you? Or at least conveniently "nuanced?"
Chuck, thank you for so bravely retracting the "lie" accusation (if only in the tiny little comment section many days late and while your headline still screams "HUCKABEE CAUGHT IN A LIE"). Very manly of you.
Does anybody else see this as an abuse of journalistic ethics? Ought not the headline be revised? Ought not the original post be taken down and replaced with an update? Ought not a new post be put up by Mr. Todd explaining his change of opinion about the original accusation?
Now, another question. Can you please lay it out for us what, exactly, you think Huckabee
did say in his Stephanopoulos interview that "absolutely was being critical of Romney at the time" ?
To make this easier for you, here's the transcript:
[1]10:23:37 GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS (ABC NEWS) (OC) Governor Romney, his religion, he's a Mormon, has become a – is going to become a big part of this campaign clearly. You're a southern Baptist, former southern Baptist preacher.
[1]10:23:45 MIKE HUCKABEE (2008 PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE) Uh-huh.
[1]10:23:46 GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS (ABC NEWS) (OC) And that denomination teaches I believe that Mormonism is a cult. How big a hurdle is that going to be for Governor Romney in this campaign?
[1]10:23:56 MIKE HUCKABEE (2008 PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE) Well, you know, I'm not sure and I don't know that anyone knows. What I can tell you is about my faith and what it means and I think people ought to look at every person who runs for office and they ought to ask them questions about who they are and what they are about and what drives their decisions. I'm not as troubled by a person who has a different faith. I'm troubled by a person who tells me their favorite faith doesn't influence their decisions. Because if a person says to me, here's my faith but it doesn't influence me at all, what it says to me is my faith isn't very significant.
[1]10:24:21 GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS (ABC NEWS) (OC) How does it influence yours?
[1]10:24:22 MIKE HUCKABEE (2008 PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE) It totally drives it. It makes everything click for me and that will explain to you why I have a passion for life but it means my pro-life position doesn't end at the birth canal. That I believe that a life is more than the gestation period. I believe life begins at conception. I just don't think it ends at birth. And that's why as a governor I fought hard to see children have medical insurance and decent schools and safe neighborhoods and drinking water and affordable housing because that's consistent with me being pro-life. I don't want to see some single mom, you know, worry and struggle that she's not going to be able to have food for her kids. I don't want some wife to have the daylights beaten out of her by some abusive husband and have nowhere to turn. Those are things that are driven because of my faith. That's not a political position. It's a faith position.
We look forward to hearing from you,
BSR