UPDATED!
Governor Mike Huckabee is
against illegal immigration and
supports the deportation of illegal immigrants captured in the U.S.
But, as recent events show, enforcing our immigration laws is not as simple as merely rounding up illegal immigrants and deporting them.
Back on May 24, 2005 we talked about Governor Mike Huckabee's stance on illegal immigration in a blog titled
"Mike Huckabee On Illegal Immigration: The Kids Matter." This post was prompted by a huge amount of criticism the Governor received for advocating prenatal care for the unborn children of immigrants and in-state tuition eligibility for Latino children who graduate from Arkansas high schools.
In a nutshell, Huckabee's stance on illegal immigration is that illegals who are caught should be deported. Period. But if they are not caught, and instead remain here to raise their families, Huckabee's pro-life sentiment drives him to support providing prenatal care for all unborn children--no questions asked. And because the Arkansas constitution dictates that all children, regardless of legal status, be provided with public education K-12, Huckabee believes those who graduate and are academically eligible deserve to be eligible for in-state tuition rates.
In other words, the children of illegal immigrants should not be punished for the crimes of their parents. The kids matter.
Since we posted that story, a new development has arisen in Arkansas that perfectly illustrates why Huckabee is right on this issue. But you don't have to take our word for it.
Here is a very interesting and important editorial about Huckabee. It is interesting because it very effectively describes his stance on illegal immigration. It is important because it was published by
The Morning News in Northwest Arkansas,
which has one of the fastest growing Latino populations in the United States.
As you read this editorial, you should remember that almost no other area in the U.S. has experienced a more rapid or more overwhelming change in its local culture than Northwest Arkansas.Several days ago, federal immigration officials, without first alerting Arkansas law enforcement, raided a poultry plant in Arkadelphia, AR. They rounded up over 100 illegal immigrants and hastily deported them. That's fine. What isn't fine is that the feds did not take the necessary time to see that some 30 children of the deportees went with them. Many of these children, some infants and many natural born American citizens,
were effectively orphaned. Now that you are up to speed, here's
The Morning News' editorial:
The Morning NewsHuckabee Right About Children Left in LurchGov. Mike Huckabee has a definite flair for infuriating people by refusing to adhere to a rigid party line. That's one of the things we appreciate most about him, although we still have our disagreements. This talent was most recently displayed when Huckabee weighed in on the recent immigration raid on an Arkadelphia poultry plant. The raid netted 119 people who were working at the plant and had bought fake IDs from a former worker. Most, if not all, of those arrested in the raid have since been deported. In a simplistic world of bumper-sticker politics the arrest and deportation of 119 illegal immigrants would be non-controversial.
No one -- including the governor -- endorses law-breaking. But in the real world there are all too often complications. There are added considerations that go beyond the simple formula of "They broke the law so they should be arrested and deported." In this case there were some 30 complications. About 30 children were left in limbo when one or both of their parents were arrested without warning and removed from the country.
Huckabee thought those children, some of whom are U.S. citizens by birth, deserved more consideration. He went beyond just saying so and directed the state Health Department and the Department of Human Services to provide whatever assistance they can to these children. Huckabee also released $1,000 from his emergency fund to buy food, clothing and even school supplies for the children.
That brought the wrath of the righteous down on the governor. Jim Harris, a spokesman for Huckabee, said the office has been getting calls from as far away as California from people irate over the governor's supposed coddling of illegal residents. But that's not what this is about.
Huckabee has never suggested that those 119 people shouldn't have been arrested and dealt with according to the law. What he has said, and we agree with him here, is that the arrests and deportations could have been better coordinated between federal, state and local agencies and that the interests of the children could and should have been taken into account. There was no urgency, nothing to justify separating these families this way.
That's what this is about and to his credit that's what Huckabee, and not his cranky callers, understands.--end--
UPDATE: Monday, August 15:
The Log Cabin Democrat reports today that the deportees
are already returning to Arkadelphia less than three weeks after the raid. A young pregnant woman, separated from her husband and children, was dropped off about a block inside Mexico and immediately made her way back across. She probably beat the immigration van. This further illustrates what is wrong with our system.
If you want to guarantee that deportees return to the U.S., separate them from their children. UPDATE II: Tuesday, August 16: U.S. Senator Mark Pryor (D-AR) says the Arkansas immigration raid described in this blog will be a case study as congress takes up immigration legislation this fall. "I do think it's a legitimate question to ask," he says. "Do we have the right protocols in place?
Emphasis added by BSR